Which of the following messages does NOT match the statements given above?
Answer Explanation:
Let’s evaluate each option and match them with the given statements:
-
Roger:
- Roger’s statement: “I am sick and will not go to work today. I should call my boss.”
- Option A says: “Roger: I won’t come to work today because I am ill. I will see a doctor.”
- Mismatch: Roger mentioned he would call his boss, but there’s no mention of seeing a doctor.
-
Paula:
- Paula’s statement: “I made a reservation at the new restaurant this evening. My sister shouldn’t be late.”
- Option B says: “Paula: We will have a great dinner! Try to arrive before 8 p.m.”
- Match: Paula is implying that they will have dinner at the restaurant, and her sister should arrive on time.
-
Luna:
- Luna’s statement: “I have English course this evening. I can’t join our family dinner. I should let my mom know.”
- Option C says: “Luna: I won’t attend the family dinner because of my English course.”
- Match: Luna explicitly states that she won’t attend the dinner because of her English class.
-
David:
- David’s statement: “I will stay late at work today. My wife should pick up our son from school.”
- Option D says: “David: Please call our son and tell him to take the bus today after school.”
- Mismatch: David said his wife should pick up their son, not that his son should take the bus.
Correct Answer:
- Option A (Roger’s message does NOT match).
This is because Roger did not mention seeing a doctor in his original statement.
Final Answer:
A) Roger: I won’t come to work today because I am ill. I will see a doctor.
Which of the following messages does NOT match the statements given above?
Answer:
Let’s compare each option with the original statements:
-
Roger’s statement:
“I am sick and will not go to work today. I should call my boss.”- Option A: “Roger: I won’t come to work today because I am ill. I will see a doctor.”
- This lines up with him being too ill to go to work.
-
Paula’s statement:
“I made a reservation at the new restaurant this evening. My sister shouldn’t be late.”- Option B: “Paula: We will have a great dinner! Try to arrive before 8 p.m.”
- This aligns with a dinner plan requiring someone to arrive on time.
-
Luna’s statement:
“I have an English course this evening. I can’t join our family dinner. I should let my mom know.”- Option C: “Luna: I won’t attend the family dinner because of my English course.”
- This directly matches Luna’s situation.
-
David’s statement:
“I will stay late at work today. My wife should pick up our son from school.”- Option D: “David: Please call our son and tell him to take the bus today after school.”
- David originally said his wife would pick up their son, not that the son should take the bus.
Therefore, the message not matching David’s original statement is Option D.
Which of the following messages does NOT match the statements given above?
Answer:
Based on the four individuals’ original statements—Roger, Paula, Luna, and David—the message that does not accurately reflect what they intended to communicate is Option D. Specifically, David originally stated that he would “stay late at work today” and that his wife should pick up their son from school. However, Option D instructs someone to “call our son and tell him to take the bus today after school,” which differs from David’s plan (i.e., his wife picking up the son).
Below is a comprehensive explanation and breakdown of how we determine that D is the mismatched message.
Table of Contents
- Overview of the Question
- Detailed Look at the Original Statements
- Comparison of Each Option
- Step-by-Step Reasoning
- Deeper Insights: Matching Details and Possible Confusions
- Common English Expressions Reflected in the Messages
- Two Practice Exercises
- Summary Table of Statements vs. Messages
- Extended Explanation (Why Mismatched, Why Matched)
- Key Takeaways and Study Tips
- Final Answer Recap
1. Overview of the Question
The question presents four short statements by four individuals—Roger, Paula, Luna, and David. Each statement describes a particular situation or intention:
- Roger is sick, will not go to work, and plans to inform his boss about it.
- Paula made a dinner reservation and wants other attendees (especially her sister) to arrive without delay.
- Luna has an English course in the evening, so she cannot attend her family’s dinner and needs to let her mother know.
- David will stay late at work, so his wife must pick up their son from school.
After the statements, there are four possible messages (A, B, C, and D). The question asks which one of these four messages contradicts (or does not match) the original statements.
In multiple-choice questions like this, you generally check each option for consistency with the related original statement:
- Does the content accurately capture the original speaker’s main idea?
- Does it add any details that contradict the original speaker’s plan or intention?
- Does it omit vital information that changes the meaning of the original plan?
By performing this consistency check, we can pinpoint the mismatched or incorrect message.
2. Detailed Look at the Original Statements
Roger’s Statement
- Roger: “I am sick and I will not go to work today. I should call my boss.”
- Key points:
- Roger is ill.
- Roger will not attend work.
- He must inform or call his boss.
- Key points:
Paula’s Statement
- Paula: “I made a reservation at the new restaurant this evening. My sister shouldn’t be late.”
- Key points:
- Paula made an evening reservation.
- She is highlighting the importance of punctuality (“My sister shouldn’t be late”).
- Key points:
Luna’s Statement
- Luna: “I have English course this evening. I can’t join our family dinner. I should let my mom know.”
- Key points:
- Luna has an English course in the evening.
- Because of her course, she cannot attend the family dinner.
- She wants to inform her mother about her absence.
- Key points:
David’s Statement
- David: “I will stay late at work today. My wife should pick up our son from school.”
- Key points:
- David is working late.
- The wife is responsible for picking up their son.
- Key points:
Each statement indicates a clear plan or intention tied to a specific reason.
3. Comparison of Each Option
3.1 Option A: Roger’s Message
Option A says:
“Roger: I won’t come to work today because I am ill. I will see a doctor.”
- Is this consistent with Roger’s statement?
- Roger’s original idea: He is sick, will not go in.
- Option A: Reinforces the same notion: “I won’t come to work today because I am ill.”
- Extra detail: “I will see a doctor.”
- While Roger’s original statement does not explicitly mention seeing a doctor, it does not contradict the overall meaning of missing work due to illness. Seeking medical help is in line with being ill, so this small addition does not create a conflict.
- Therefore, Option A basically matches Roger’s message, focusing on the same main point: He is not attending work due to illness.
3.2 Option B: Paula’s Message
Option B says:
“Paula: We will have a great dinner! Try to arrive before 8 p.m.”
- Paula’s original idea: She made a reservation for the evening, expecting that her sister (and presumably others) should not be late.
- Option B: Reinforces the dinner context and a request to be on time.
- Although it uses a direct approach—“We will have a great dinner! Try to arrive before 8 p.m.”—this logically aligns with Paula’s original statement:
- Restaurant reservation → scheduled time for dinner → request for no lateness (implying an arrival time, presumably around 8 p.m.).
- Therefore, Option B matches Paula’s scenario quite well.
3.3 Option C: Luna’s Message
Option C says:
“Luna: I won’t attend the family dinner because of my English course.”
- Luna’s original idea: She cannot attend the family dinner since she has an English course in the evening.
- Option C: Repeats exactly that.
- Conclusion: A direct match.
3.4 Option D: David’s Message
Option D says:
“David: Please call our son and tell him to take the bus today after school.”
- David’s original idea: He will stay late at work. Therefore, his wife must pick up their son from school.
- Option D: Tells a different story—calling the son to take the bus rather than the wife picking him up. This changes the original plan David mentioned.
- Such a change is a direct contradiction to the statement that the wife would handle pick-up responsibilities.
4. Step-by-Step Reasoning
-
Identify each person’s plan:
- Roger: Not going to work → Illness.
- Paula: Dinner reservation → Expect punctuality.
- Luna: Cannot come to dinner → Has an English course.
- David: Working late → Wife will do the pick-up.
-
Match person to option:
- A (Roger): “Not coming to work,” ill → Good match with “I am sick,” only adding “I will see a doctor.”
- B (Paula): “We will have a great dinner,” arrive before 8 p.m. → Aligned with “New restaurant reservation” and “Don’t be late.”
- C (Luna): “Won’t attend dinner,” specifically because of the English course → Matches perfectly.
- D (David): “Call our son,” “Son should take the bus” → Different from the original plan to have the wife pick the son up.
-
Determine the mismatch:
- The mismatch is Option D because David’s plan is not about the son taking a bus at all.
Thus, with minimal confusion, we can verify that D is the odd one out.
5. Deeper Insights: Matching Details and Possible Confusions
In multiple-choice questions related to statements and matching answers, small details can change the entire meaning. While Option A adds a detail about seeing a doctor (not explicitly stated by Roger), it does not conflict with the primary message that he is sick and cannot work. In Option B, the specific time (before 8 p.m.) is consistent with “You shouldn’t be late,” especially if the dinner reservation is around 8 p.m.
In contrast, Option D transforms David’s arrangement from “my wife must pick up our kid” to “our son must take the bus.” That is not a minor shift in detail; it entirely rewrites David’s arrangement and, therefore, is the choice that does not match.
6. Common English Expressions Reflected in the Messages
Below are some typical English expressions or phrasing patterns that appear in these statements and messages:
-
“I won’t come to work today because I am ill.”
- A standard way of informing an employer or colleagues of absence due to sickness.
- Key grammar: Negative future intention using “won’t,” combined with a reason introduced by “because.”
-
“Try to arrive before 8 p.m.”
- Soft imperative or suggestion for punctuality.
- Key grammar: “Try to + verb” indicates a polite request.
-
“I can’t join our family dinner.”
- Standard expression to indicate an inability to attend an event.
- Often used when giving reasons for missing a social/family gathering.
-
“Please call our son and tell him to…”
- Example of an imperative statement that requests action.
- This phrasing typically arises when someone can’t perform the task themselves but is delegating it.
Each of these expressions helps English learners or test-takers recognize how personal messages might be structured in everyday conversation or short notes.
7. Two Practice Exercises
Exercise 1: Paraphrasing the Statements
Rewrite each person’s original statement in a slightly different style:
- Roger: “I’m feeling terrible, so I’m missing work today, and I need to call the office.”
- Paula: “My reservation for tonight is set. I’m hoping everyone makes it on time!”
- Luna: “I have an English class in the evening, so I have to skip the family dinner. I’ll inform Mom.”
- David: “I have to work overtime tonight; my wife should pick our child up from school.”
This exercise helps confirm you understand the meaning behind each original statement.
Exercise 2: Creating New Mismatched Statements
Try writing one incorrect message for each person. For example:
- For Luna, a mismatched statement might be: “I will go shopping instead of joining the family dinner.” Clearly, that’s not what Luna said—she must attend an English course.
By practicing writing incorrect messages, you reinforce your ability to identify discrepancies.
8. Summary Table of Statements vs. Messages
| Person | Original Statement | Option | Message | Match / Mismatch |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Roger | “I am sick. I won’t go to work. I should call my boss.” | A | “I won’t come to work today because I am ill. I will see a doctor.” | Matches (minor add) |
| Paula | “I reserved a spot at a new restaurant. My sister shouldn’t be late.” | B | “We will have a great dinner! Try to arrive before 8 p.m.” | Matches |
| Luna | “I have an English course tonight. Can’t attend family dinner.” | C | “I won’t attend the family dinner because of my English course.” | Matches |
| David | “I will stay late at work. My wife should pick up our son from school.” | D | “Please call our son and tell him to take the bus today after school.” | Mismatch |
In reviewing the table:
- A: Good enough match for Roger.
- B: Consistent with Paula’s dinner plan.
- C: Exactly what Luna said about skipping dinner.
- D: Conflicts with David’s original plan about how his son gets home.
9. Extended Explanation (Why Mismatched, Why Matched)
-
Roger (Option A)
- Roger’s statement is about illness and missing work. Option A also states the same reason. The mention of “seeing a doctor” does not create a direct contradiction.
-
Paula (Option B)
- Paula reserved a restaurant, evening time, does not want tardiness. Option B effectively rewords “Don’t be late” to “arrive before 8 p.m.” This is consistent.
-
Luna (Option C)
- Luna can’t attend family dinner because of her English class. Option C says exactly that: “I won’t attend the family dinner because of my English course.”
-
David (Option D)
- Original plan: David’s wife picks up their son. The message says the son should use the bus. That is not what David stated.
- This mismatch is significant enough to be the outlier.
10. Key Takeaways and Study Tips
- Double-Check for Consistency: When dealing with statements and matching them to short messages, always ensure the main subject, the action, and the reasoning align exactly.
- Minor Deviations vs. Contradictions: Small alterations (such as “I will see a doctor” for someone already ill) might be acceptable, whereas an outright contradictory action (“take the bus” vs. “wife picking up the son”) is a complete mismatch.
- Context Clues: Pay attention to who is responsible for doing what. In David’s statement, the emphasis is on the wife picking up their son—this is the crucial point that is contradicted in Option D.
- Short Answers with Big Impact: In short question-answer formats, a couple of words can completely change a statement’s meaning.
Tip: If you are ever unsure, try rewriting both the original statement and the candidate answer to see if they align in meaning, subject, and intent.
11. Final Answer Recap
The option that does NOT match the statements given above is Option D (David’s Message).
- Roger’s Message (A): Consistent with being sick and not going to work.
- Paula’s Message (B): Aligned with the dinner reservation and timeliness.
- Luna’s Message (C): Accurate reflection of her English class preventing her from joining dinner.
- David’s Message (D): Contradicts his plan because it suggests the son should take the bus instead of having the wife pick him up.
Hence, the correct choice for the mismatch is D.
