According to legal precedent, when is a school considered deliberately indifferent in cases of sexual harassment?

Question Answer
1

according to legal precedent, when is a school considered deliberately indifferent in cases of sexual harassment?

2

Deliberate Indifference Standard under Title IX

Under established legal precedent (primarily the landmark U.S. Supreme Court decision Gebser v. Lago Vista Independent School District, 1998, and Davis v. Monroe County Board of Education, 1999), a school is considered deliberately indifferent when its response to known sexual harassment is clearly unreasonable in light of the known circumstances.

:pushpin: KEY POINTS:

  • Actual Knowledge: An official with the authority to institute corrective measures must have actual knowledge of the harassment, rather than constructive notice (meaning “should have known” is not enough).
  • Clearly Unreasonable Response: The school’s action—or complete inaction—must amount to a deliberate choice to ignore the risk, causing the student to undergo harassment or making them vulnerable to it.
  • Deprivation of Access: The indifference must effectively deny the victim equal access to the institution’s educational programs or activities.